If I correctly understand the pretty graph in the about section, this site is also supposed to serve as a forum, yet I am getting the impression that discussions are discouraged and the simple question-answer model preferred. So I want to ask you if you think it's OK to post a question which clearly is not a case of someone wanting to learn something they don't know, but rather which aims to open a discussion so as to learn about the different points of view, or simply get a little more social.

From what I see in the stats, the site does not fare terribly well. Perhaps an attempt at giving it a slightly more casual character can help improve it?

1 Answer 1


The StackExchange sites are Q&A sites, i.e. Question & Answer sites. Check this MSO question about this topic: "Is StackOverflow a forum?". It's about SO but still related, I think. :)

Someone asks questions and the community answers. There is no discussion, except for this meta site, where we treat about the site and not about the site's topic.

There even exists a close-reason against questions inviting for discussion:

enter image description here

Not only that, even questions can't be too scope-wide, as you must ask for something specific. Not necessarily something too specific, i.e. a particular example, but a specific topic/question.

  • Well, oh well. What about questions to which a single, widely accepted answer does not exist? Say I asked "Is phoneme a psychological reality?" -- that's something that can be discussed, there are arguments on both sides and nobody knows what the truth really is. Is this type of questions out, too?
    – kamil-s
    Commented Feb 28, 2012 at 0:29
  • @KamilS. Yes and no. You can ask questions that you don't know the answer to, and if an answer doesn't exist, you'll get answers like "There isn't an answer yet"; But you must preferably ask questions about problems and situations you face. You can ask theoretical questions but they must be reasonably scoped and specific.
    – Alenanno
    Commented Feb 28, 2012 at 13:42

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .