2

Since our entering Beta until now, we've had some requests for corpora with various features... Unfortunately, while I still want them On Topic, they are dangerously on the edge. The reason is simple: asking for such lists is a sort of invitation to people to "post my own take on it"... This might lead to many equal answers that mean closing the question as not constructive.

What guidelines would the community advise to make sure we can keep this questions on a high quality level? What would you ask the OP to include in their question in order to improve the question so that it's not just a "gimme teh codez" question?

1

Newest thoughts

I've been thinking about this a lot and it more and more reminds me of our policy on travel.SE to allow recommendation questions if and only if the requirements are very specific: 1

Good recommendation questions have special requirements which make them too specific to fail the "general reference" test: 2

Good recommendation questions fall into the "long tail" category of questions that Stack Exchange specifically embraces: 3

Of course there is a chance for recommendation questions to have overly specific requirements, in which case they may fail the "too localized" test: 4

Would some version of this policy be a good starting point for a policy on how to decide between rejecting and accepting corpus request questions?

Here's a question which seems to fit with such guidelines: Most common english words from newspapers, books and magazines

Original thoughts

Will there be "many equal answers"? How much is many and why are we guessing? The beta stats tell us we want on average 2.5 answers per question, but if we close such questions because they "might" get more answers than this how will we know?

Why not as a minimum use this beta phase to beta test such things rather than try to make policy based on assumptions?

On the big three sites like Stack Overflow it's normal and good that people post their own take on programming problems. The way to find whether and which one is more than equal is to use the voting system.

Another thing we can do is include links to corpora sites in our list of resources: Creating a list of linguistic resources

  • Well, I wouldn't compare SO to Ling. Your own take on a code is different than your take on a "google search". :P For "many questions" I mean when we start to reach 6, 7, 10 answers. Not that they are "bad" per se, but it means that the question is too broad. – Alenanno Jun 18 '12 at 8:17
  • I thing many parts of Ling don't compare well to SO but perhaps the NLP and CL questions will compare pretty well. And those areas cross over with corpora questions. – hippietrail Jun 18 '12 at 8:25

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .